从牛叉私校Eton和Winchester的学生今年A Level (Pre-U)考试被作弊看英国考试系统的不靠谱!

事件回顾,
[ol]

  • Eton的经济科主任以及副校长Mo Tanweer是CIE (Cambridge International Examinations)的Pre-U Economics的Examiners之一,就是说他参加了出题。
  • Mo Tanweer考试以前把其中的一个考卷Paper 2的答案发给了Eton学Economics的学生
  • Eton的一个学生为了追Dawne House女校的一个女孩把答案转给了她
  • 这个女孩被恶心到了,就在自己的那个学校举报了这事情,然后就曝光了。
  • CIS的处理结果是,Eton学生的Paper 2考试作废,但因为学生不是有意作弊所有没有惩罚学生,最后Eton的学生PreU Economics成绩是用其它几个Papers的平均分来计算。
  • 后来又是爆料Winchester的老师Laurence Wolf也做了同样的事情。
  • 再后来又爆料另外一个牛X私校Radley的老师improve学生的作品。
    [/ol]

评论:从这件事情看,英国的这个A Level考试系统不靠谱啊,Mo Tanweer等类出考题的人就算是没有泄露题,他也可以有针对有偏向的引导学生学习和复习啊。出考题的人里面很大比例的老师是来自很多牛叉私校,这让人很难信服这些学校的考试成绩。非常欣赏Eton的处理结果,把学生的利益放在老师和学校的利益前面。

Public school cheating scandal began when lovestruck Eton pupil tried to chat up private schoolgirl by telling her he had leaked exam details

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4848940/Eton-cheating-scandal-brought-light-schoolgirl.html#ixzz4roq6jReG

A cheating scandal that rocked Eton College may have first come to light when a student tried to impress of girl by bragging about the leaked exam details he was in possession of.
Two disgraced scholars left their professions at Eton and Winchester College, after answers to exams were ‘inadvertently’ emailed to students. They were Mo Tanweer, head of Economics and Politics and one of Eton’s principal examiners, as wells as Winchester College’s Laurence Wolff. Mr Wolff is alleged to have given student information on what exam questions would be included in two papers.

Now it has emerged that concerns over exam cheating were raised by a student at Downe House, an independent school for girls. It is thought that she and a male Eton student befriended one another and that he sent her the email in an attempt to impress her. ‘It turns out that one of the boys had really put his foot in it, because he’d let slip to a girl he was trying to chat up at Downe House,’ a source told The Telegraph. ‘She was outraged and reported it to the school, which led to this sorry chain of events.’

The girl’s complaint is thought to have sparked a spate of investigations by Cambridge International Examinations (CIE). It was revealed that Winchester College’s head of art, Laurence Wolff, was behind the leaks. Mr Wolff was suspended pending an investigation, and was later convinced to take early retirement. The letter sent from Head Master Simon Henderson to boys at Eton College, Windsor

Pupils at Eton had also been passed details of the exam from a pupil at Winchester, which resulted in a second set of exam marks being voided. Mo Tanweer (above) left his job at Eton after an investigation revealed he had emailed three colleagues practice questions which ‘breached exam security’。 Members of Eton’s economics department had also come forward to raise concerns that the department’s head had also leaked confidential information about upcoming Pre-U economics papers. Mr Tanweer and Mr Wolff were both examiners for CIE.

On Thursday, Ofqual launched a review into whether teachers should be permitted to set exam questions in the subjects they teach. The Commons education select committee are also expected to discuss probe the scandal when Parliament resumes. Downe House’s headteacher, Emma McKendirck, said that the school looked into concerns after being raised by a pupil.

Simon Henderson, Head Master at Eton, said students affected had been ‘inadvertent recipients’ of the information.
Eton (file pic) Headmaster Simon Henderson told students that because of the confidential information that had been passed on to them, through no fault of their own, their marks in the exam would not be accepted by the board for the Cambridge Pre-U qualification

Eton Headmaster Simon Henderson told students that because of the confidential information that had been passed on to them, through no fault of their own, their marks in the exam would not be accepted by the board for the Cambridge Pre-U qualification

Mr Henderson sent a letter to candidates for the economics exam explaining that practice questions emailed as part of the revision programme were deemed to breach confidentiality, voiding marks. It is not clear how the pupils became ‘inadvertent recipients’ of the questions, but Mr Tanweer is the only person implicated. The boys’ overall marks would instead be calculated from the results of the previous two tests on the certificate’s syllabus.

Exam cheating scandal: How a lovestruck pupil’s boast sparked investigation
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/2017/09/02/exam-cheating-scandal-lovestruck-pupils-boast-sparked-investigation/

Public school exam ‘cheating’ scandal deepens as Eton is hit by leak in second subject and Radley College teacher ‘improved students’ work’
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4838770/Public-school-exam-cheating-scandal-deepens.html#ixzz4rorc2d2N

More top public schools dragged into exam cheating scandal
http://metro.co.uk/2017/08/28/more-top-public-schools-dragged-into-exam-cheating-scandal-6883761/#ixzz4rorxIfbj

Public school cheating scandal sparks review into exam rules
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/public-school-cheating-exams-questions-papers-ofqual-eton-college-winchester-radley-charterhouse-a7922976.html

Third top private school under investigation following exams ‘cheating’ scandal
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/education/education-news/top-private-school-exams-cheating-scandal-eton-college-winchester-charterhouse-school-cambridge-a7916811.html

‘Cheating’ scandal: Headteachers shift blame to exam boards
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/2017/08/29/exam-cheating-scandal-teachers-risk-placed-impossible-position/

Three of Britain’s top schools accused of helping pupils CHEAT in exams with one professor suspended over scandal
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4337205/three-of-britains-top-schools-accused-of-helping-pupils-cheat-in-exams-with-one-professor-suspended-over-scandal/

垃圾学校

垃圾老师

{:5_133:}

我觉得学校一点都不垃圾,出了事情首先是保护学生,学校的立场是no boy to blame,然后学生的成绩也基本没有被影响,如果paper 2是最难的一个paper,那学生还赚了。

能够混到那个位置,这个老师也不垃圾吧,他2015才到Eton的,估计是太想出成绩所以做了这种事情。

即当裁判员 又当运动员
这样的事还有很多,只是没证据,抓不到而已

这不是更加证明了私校的“优越”性?

无论如何,都是普通学校的学生成为受害者。

虽然比例小,但有些公校老师也有参加出题的,整个系统很难杜绝作弊。

这样看来,还是的花钱进私校啊,老师随便漏点重点啥的,抵别的学校学生辛苦奋斗好几年的。。。这世界太tm不公平。。。

还是中国高考最公平了。。。。出题老师提前几个月被“看守”起来,露題泄题会被判刑,学生会被取消当年入学资格

Eton里面老师风气和氛围都不好

这边作弊,不代表国内的高考就公平了。。。
各地卷子不一样,这个跟光明正大的作弊有什么区别。。。

有人的地方,就有不公平,没办法的

卷子不一样肯定不公平,但是舞弊这件事上说,中国确实做的比英国好。

这有什么啊!我们国内中学也一样啊。我们老师都是负责教育局出中考高考题的老师,所以我们都trained to 揣摩出题人的思路,然后拿高分。这就是好学校跟差学校的区别。我们学校老师牛,学生跟着沾光,没什么问题吧?

揣摩出题思路和出题人有意无意的泄露还是有区别的吧。

我们系用很多年的数据做了A level成绩和degree classification的相关性研究,结论是相关性不大。

正因为A level的靠谱度很低,Cambridge才搞了PreU,另外牛桥录取很多专业除了面试还增加了自己的考试,其它一些学校也慢慢向这个方面发展。

这老师也太蠢了吧。直接泄露答案,不是等着人揪小辫子么。

而且如果我没看错,eton的学生是知道拿到的是答案是嘛,所以才向别校女孩炫耀,人家才会被恶心。那eton的学生也有责任,没有举报老师啊。

一看什么Mo就知道是包头巾的,没好人:lol